Book that is a Jar

When it’s a Jar by Tom Holt

I love Tom Holt; most of the time he gets it right. My all time favourite of his is You don’t have to be evil to work here, but it helps. My problem is, I have read loads of his book one after another and can’t really distinguished between them anymore. He is clever in a way I appreciate – mixing reality with ridiculousness. So I was excited when the ‘Jar’ showed up on our book club’s list.

‘Maurice has just killed a dragon with a breadknife.’ That’s the description of the book. I was hooked. You can imagine my disappointment as this was the only dragon in the book.

I liked the idea of the multiverses etc but the writing felt bit forced and Tom Holt was trying too hard to be clever. The plot wasn’t the strongest point, there were snippets of  good ideas but it didn’t really work as a whole. For me there wasn’t enough fantasy for a book that promotes killing dragons.

The ending was very linear, no anticipation or climax, just a full stop. It also didn’t help that the Maurice character was without ‘flavour’ and he never managed to own the role of ‘unexpected hero’. Also there were not enough dragons (not sure if I mentioned that).

However it was interesting to read it after 1984 – there were parts that echoed the feelings from 1984 – and I can’t really explain why.

Another issue – not Tom Holt’s fault this time. This book also has a predecessor – Doughnut. Which we only found out after finishing the ‘Jar’. I guess that’s why our reading experience was mildly confusing and I wasn’t always sure what was happening. Of course I have read the ‘Doughnut’ book after the ‘Jar’. I liked it better.

1 Comment (+add yours?)

  1. trentpmcd
    Feb 03, 2015 @ 19:27:01

    So, someone who’s blog is sub-titled “dragons are real… just so you know” would think this of a book just having one dragon: “Also there were not enough dragons (not sure if I mentioned that)”? 😉



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Out of Print

Fiction authors and their shorts

Ariel Hudnall

the writings, musings, and photography of a dream smith

Roaming at Large

Poems & Photos by DM Shepherd


Paranormal Romance


The greatest site in all the land!

Black Bean Queen

Running, plant based food, & navigating life

The Exceptional Everyday

The ordinary is the magic.


My words will either attract a strong mind or offend a weak one.

Elan Mudrow



Life is Hard

Tourmaline .

Miniature Diorama Photographer

katerina marks

mixed-media artist

The Dictionary of Victorian Insults & Niceties

Together we can give the nineteenth century a voice in the twenty-first century.

Kat's Scribbles

where chaos gives birth to poetic expression

Through the Lens of my Life

thoughts and images from my perspective


It is not down in any map; true places never are.

harold guenthner

apostrophe ess

%d bloggers like this: